WEGA Max
Homepage » Knowledgebase » What is photon efficacy and why does it matter for greenhouse lighting?

What is photon efficacy and why does it matter for greenhouse lighting?

Photon efficacy tells you how many photosynthetically active photons a luminaire produces for each joule of electricity it uses. It is measured in µmol/J. A higher number means the fixture turns more electricity into usable light. That makes it a helpful figure for comparing fixtures and estimating energy use, but it says little about how the light will work for your crop. This article answers the questions growers ask most often about photon efficacy, from measurement and benchmarks to energy costs and datasheet checks.

How is photon efficacy measured in µmol/J?

Photon efficacy is calculated by dividing the total photon output of a luminaire (in µmol per second) by the electrical power it uses (in watts). One watt equals one joule per second, so the result is given in µmol/J. A fixture that emits 2,000 µmol/s on 1,000 W has an efficacy of 2.0 µmol/J.

Manufacturers usually measure photon output in a calibrated laboratory, using an integrating sphere or a goniometer. The test captures all the light leaving the fixture and counts the photons in the photosynthetically active range, normally 400 to 700 nm. Power is measured at the same time at the driver input.

Test conditions matter. Efficacy can change with ambient temperature, dimming level, driver settings and the age of the fixture. A value measured at full output in a stable laboratory may differ from what you see in a warm greenhouse at partial dimming. It is therefore worth asking under which conditions a value was measured.

What is a good photon efficacy for greenhouse fixtures?

A good photon efficacy is one that suits your crop, your greenhouse and your energy situation, and that has been verified by an independent or well-documented test. Modern professional LED fixtures generally convert electricity into photons more efficiently than HPS fixtures. Still, no single number defines “good” for every project.

Efficacy has improved over time for both technologies, and it varies between models and generations. Instead of aiming for a fixed benchmark, compare candidate fixtures side by side, using the same test method and the same operating conditions.

What counts as good in practice depends on your growing situation. A propagation area has different light needs from a high-wire tomato crop. Greenhouse height and construction affect how much of the emitted light reaches the plants. Locations with plenty of natural daylight may need supplemental light less often, and efficacy matters more when electricity is a large part of your operating costs. LED and HPS also release heat differently, which can change your heating strategy.

How does photon efficacy differ from photosynthetic photon efficacy?

In everyday horticultural use, the two terms are very close. Photosynthetic photon efficacy (PPE) is photon efficacy measured specifically in the photosynthetically active range of 400 to 700 nm, in µmol/J. “Photon efficacy” is the broader phrase, and it is often used as shorthand for the same value.

The difference lies in what is counted. PPE counts only photons in the PAR range, which plants use for photosynthesis. Some datasheets also include far-red photons (700 to 800 nm), which fall outside the standard PAR definition. If a datasheet adds far-red, its total photon figure will not match a strict PPE figure for the same fixture.

Two other terms can cause confusion. Luminous efficacy (lm/W) measures light as the human eye sees it. It does not describe plant-usable light, so it should not be used to rate horticultural fixtures. System efficacy describes the whole system, including the driver and other electronics. It can be lower than the efficacy of the LED chips alone because of losses in those components. When you compare PPE and system efficacy, check what was included in the power measurement.

Does higher efficacy always mean better crop results?

No. Higher efficacy means a fixture produces more photons for the same amount of electricity. Crop results depend on how much light reaches the plants, when it is delivered and in what spectrum. Efficacy describes energy conversion, not crop response.

To judge what a lighting system means for your crop, look at these factors as well:

  • PPFD: the number of photons reaching each square metre per second, in µmol/m²/s. It describes the light intensity at crop level at a given moment.
  • DLI: the total light received over 24 hours, in mol/m²/day. It combines daylight and supplemental light.
  • Light distribution: how uniformly light is spread across the crop, which affects how evenly plants grow.
  • Spectrum: the spectral composition can influence plant shape and development. Effects vary by crop and cultivar.
  • Photoperiod: crops have biological requirements for lighting duration that cannot be shifted freely.

A fixture with excellent efficacy can still perform poorly if it hangs at the wrong height, creates uneven light or delivers a spectrum that does not suit your crop. PPFD and DLI targets differ by crop, cultivar, growth stage and growing conditions, so they should be set with agronomic input rather than copied from a general benchmark.

How does photon efficacy affect greenhouse energy costs?

Efficacy determines how much electricity you need to deliver a certain amount of light. If two fixtures deliver the same number of photons, the one with the higher efficacy uses less power. Over many lighting hours, this difference can lower your electricity consumption, depending on your conditions.

Efficacy is only one part of the cost picture. The actual energy bill also depends on the number of lighting hours, because more hours increase the value of every efficiency gain. Electricity prices that vary during the day change when lighting is most economical. Your control strategy matters too: dimming based on daylight, accumulated DLI and energy prices can help you avoid using light that adds little value for the crop.

Heat plays a role as well. HPS releases more heat than LED, which can offset some heating demand in cooler seasons. With LED, that balance shifts, which may change your heating and climate strategy. Finally, total cost of ownership includes investment, maintenance, lifetime and flexibility for future changes, not just running costs.

For these reasons, a move from HPS to LED is not automatically beneficial in every greenhouse. The result depends on your crop, climate, energy contract and existing installation. A realistic comparison uses your own operating hours and prices.

What should growers check when comparing fixture specifications?

When comparing fixtures, check how the efficacy was measured, what the value includes and whether it reflects real operating conditions. A headline µmol/J number is only useful if you know the test method, the power basis and the output level it applies to.

Use this checklist when you review datasheets:

  1. Efficacy type: is it PPE (400 to 700 nm), or does it include far-red photons?
  2. Power basis: is it measured at the driver input, and does it reflect system efficacy?
  3. Test conditions: at what temperature and output level was it measured?
  4. Test source: was it measured by an accredited laboratory, and is the report available?
  5. Photon output and PPFD: what does the fixture deliver at your mounting height?
  6. Light distribution: is there a lighting plan showing uniformity across your crop area?
  7. Spectrum: does it suit your crop and growth stage?
  8. Dimming and controls: which functions are supported, and are they compatible with your climate computer? Not all systems support every function.
  9. Lifetime and maintenance: how does output hold up over time, and what does service involve?
  10. Upgrade path: can modules, drivers or sensors be changed later?

A lighting plan made for your own greenhouse is a more reliable basis for comparison than datasheets alone.

How Agrolux helps with photon efficacy and fixture selection

At Agrolux, we help growers look beyond a single µmol/J figure and judge lighting for their own greenhouse. Efficacy is one input. Your crop, daylight, greenhouse structure, energy prices and cultivation goals decide which approach fits.

We start from the crop and the way you grow it. Our specialists can work with you on a lighting plan that considers your greenhouse height, location and existing technology, and on light measurements that show how light reaches your crop, not only how much a fixture emits. We discuss both LED and HPS objectively, including their effects on heat and greenhouse climate. Our agronomists and plant scientists can help you think about light and spectrum in relation to your crop. We also advise on dynamic dimming strategies that take daylight, DLI targets, photoperiod and energy prices into account. With modular platforms such as LYRA™, you can start with one configuration and adapt it as your requirements change.

If you would like to compare fixture specifications or review your lighting strategy, you are welcome to discuss your greenhouse and crop with our specialists. Visit our Agrolux homepage to get in touch, or browse our project portfolio to see how we approach different greenhouse situations.

Related Articles

Light Measurements

If you are in need of a professional light measurement executed according to the official WUR light measurement protocol please e-mail us at service@gavitainternational.com or give us a call.