WEGA Max
Startpagina » Kennisbank » What should growers consider when upgrading an existing greenhouse lighting system?

What should growers consider when upgrading an existing greenhouse lighting system?

When you upgrade an existing greenhouse lighting system, start with the crop. Look at what your plants need, then check the condition of your current installation, how new lights will work with your climate and control systems, the full cost over time, and the timing of the work. Results depend on your crop, daylight levels, energy prices and greenhouse structure. This article answers six practical questions to help you plan a greenhouse lighting upgrade with fewer surprises.

How do you audit your current lighting system before upgrading?

You audit your current system by measuring what the installation delivers at crop level and comparing it with what your crop needs. Start with light levels and evenness at crop height. Then check the age and condition of the fixtures, the electrical capacity and your control setup.

Many growers know the installed wattage of their system but not how the light is spread at canopy level. A light measurement across the greenhouse shows where PPFD (Photosynthetic Photon Flux Density, measured in µmol/m²/s) is too high, too low or uneven. PPFD is the light intensity at one moment. DLI (Daily Light Integral, in mol/m²/day) is the total light the crop receives over 24 hours. You need both: PPFD shows how the installation performs, and DLI shows what the crop actually receives once daylight, dimming and day length are included.

Record your crop results alongside the measurements. If growth or production is uneven in certain zones, the audit can show whether light distribution plays a part. A practical audit looks at:

  • Light output and evenness: measured at crop level, not only at the fixture.
  • Fixture condition: lamp ageing, reflector wear, ballast or driver faults and hours run.
  • Electrical capacity: grid connection, cabling, protection and switching.
  • Structure: mounting points, load capacity and shading from the roof and gutters.
  • Controls and climate integration: what your current system can switch, dim and log.
  • Energy data: actual consumption per lighting hour and per season.

Should you retrofit with LED or replace the whole system?

You can retrofit when your structure, electrical infrastructure and controls can support new luminaires. You may need to replace the whole system when they cannot. The right choice depends on your crop, your energy prices and what you want from the installation over the next 10 to 15 years.

An HPS to LED greenhouse conversion is not automatically the best choice in every situation. Compare the two technologies on more than electricity use:

Factor HPS LED
Photon efficacy Lower than modern LED Generally higher
Heat output Significant radiant heat that can contribute to greenhouse heating Less radiant heat, so more heat may come from your heating system
Light distribution Top lighting with a wide pattern Varies by design, with options for top and interlighting
Spectrum Fixed Can be tailored to the crop
Dimming Limited Usually broad, depending on the driver and control
Initial investment Lower per fixture Higher per fixture
Maintenance Lamp replacement cycles Fewer replacements, but driver and component support matter

The heat balance deserves attention. In a cool climate, HPS heat can offset part of the heating demand, and removing it may raise gas or heat costs. In warmer regions or seasons, lower radiant heat can make climate control easier. A greenhouse LED retrofit works best when you model this effect for your own greenhouse and crop.

A hybrid approach can also work. Some growers convert one part of the greenhouse first and keep HPS in other zones until budget or cropping plans allow more. Modular greenhouse lighting supports this step-by-step path, because reusable structural components and expandable systems can reduce the need to replace complete luminaires when technology or cultivation requirements change.

What spectrum and light intensity does each crop need?

Each crop needs a different light intensity, DLI and spectrum, and the right values change with variety, growth stage, season and natural daylight. Tomatoes, cucumbers, strawberries, leafy greens and ornamentals all respond differently, so no single target fits every grower.

Before you choose new lights, define your production goal. Do you want higher yield, earlier harvest, better quality or steady production all year? Then work out how much supplemental light you need on top of daylight. A greenhouse in northern Europe and one in a sunnier region need very different amounts. Growth stage matters too: young plants, vegetative growth and fruit set may each need a different approach.

Day length is another limit. Many crops need a set photoperiod, so you cannot freely move light between hours. Spectrum also plays a role. The balance of red and blue, white light and far-red can influence plant shape and development, but effects vary between crops and growing conditions. Test on a small area before you scale up.

Research continues in this area. Institutions such as Wageningen University & Research study how different spectra affect crops, including strawberries. Treat spectrum claims with care and ask for evidence that fits your crop and conditions.

How do lighting controls and climate systems fit together?

Lighting controls and climate systems work together by sharing data and setpoints, so light, heat, humidity and ventilation can respond to each other. A well-integrated setup can help you dim lights when daylight is sufficient, work toward a DLI target and respond to energy prices.

Good greenhouse lighting controls do more than switch lights on and off. Depending on the system, they may dim by daylight level, respect photoperiod limits and react to electricity prices or radiation forecasts. Not every control system supports every function, so check what your climate computer and luminaires can actually exchange.

Keep two terms separate. Dimming changes the light intensity. Dynamic spectrum control changes the spectral composition of the light. They are related but different, and your hardware must support the one you want.

Check these points before you buy:

  1. Which communication protocol does your climate computer use, and do the new luminaires support it?
  2. Can you control lights in zones, rows or groups?
  3. Does the system log energy use and light output?
  4. Can it connect to light sensors and weather forecasts?
  5. Is wired or wireless connectivity better for your greenhouse layout?

Remember the climate effect too. If you change from HPS to LED, your heating, screening and ventilation strategy may need adjusting to match the new heat balance.

How do you calculate the real cost and payback of an upgrade?

You calculate real cost and payback by looking at the total cost of ownership over the lifetime of the system, not just the purchase price. Include installation, electrical work, controls, energy, maintenance, heating changes and any change in crop results. Then test the outcome against different energy price scenarios.

For a greenhouse lighting energy efficiency project, build a simple model that covers these items:

  • Capital costs: luminaires, mounting, cabling, controls, grid upgrades and installation labour.
  • Energy costs: expected consumption based on your lighting hours, dimming strategy and electricity tariff.
  • Heating effects: extra heating demand if you remove HPS heat.
  • Maintenance: lamp replacement, cleaning and service.
  • Residual value and flexibility: whether parts can be reused or expanded later.
  • Crop effects: possible changes in yield, quality or timing, treated carefully and not assumed.

Do not rely on a single payback figure from a brochure. No supplier can guarantee savings or yield gains, because the outcome depends on your installation, control strategy, crop and energy market. Run a conservative case and an optimistic case, and see whether the project still makes sense in both. If investors or purchasing teams are involved, give them a clear model with stated assumptions so decisions rest on your own data.

When is the best time to upgrade without hurting production?

The best time is usually between crops, or during the lowest-light and lowest-production part of your cycle, when the greenhouse can be cleared or worked on in sections. The exact timing depends on your crop schedule, delivery lead times and installation capacity.

Plan the project backwards from your preferred installation window. Design, ordering, delivery and electrical work can take months, so allow for this early. Working in sections, one compartment at a time, keeps part of the greenhouse in production. A crop changeover or fallow period usually causes the least disruption, and it helps to avoid upgrading just before the period when you rely most on supplemental light.

A small trial area can show how a new spectrum or intensity performs with your crop before a full rollout. Also prepare your team: train staff on the new controls and set up monitoring before the first full season. After installation, allow time to commission the system, check light measurements against the plan and tune your control settings.

How Agrolux helps with upgrading your greenhouse lighting

At Agrolux, we help you plan an upgrade around your own greenhouse, crop and goals, not around a standard product choice. We combine lighting technology, agronomic knowledge and practical support, so you can compare options with clear information.

Our support can include light measurements and a light distribution analysis to show how your current installation performs at crop level, and lighting plans based on your crop, location, structure and existing technology. We work with both LED and HPS, so we can discuss what suits your situation, including partial or phased conversions. We can also give input on light strategy for crops such as tomatoes, cucumbers, strawberries, leafy greens and ornamentals, and advise on controls, connectivity and linking lighting with your climate system. Where it fits your plans, solutions like LYRA™ use reusable structural components, which can reduce the need to replace complete luminaires as requirements change.

You can see examples of our work in our project portfolio. If you are considering an upgrade, you are welcome to contact our specialists at Agrolux to talk through your greenhouse, crop and lighting requirements.

Gerelateerde artikelen

Lichtmetingen

Heeft u behoefte aan een professionele lichtmeting die volgens de officiële normen wordt uitgevoerd? WUR-lichtmeetprotocol Stuur ons een e-mail naar service@gavitainternational.com Of bel ons even.